We tried 12 ketchup brands to perfect your picnic or backyard barbecue

Tomato ketchup is so ubiquitous that it’s easy to dismiss it as a simple sauce to be paired with french fries, meatloaf, scrambled eggs and, if you’re far away from Chicago, a hot dog. (On that, we do judge: Don’t!) But there’s a deceptive complexity to ketchup.

Chef Christopher Prosperi, my longtime friend in Connecticut, always said ketchup combined all five basic tastes: sweet, sour, bitter, salty and umami. The Food & Dining staff sampled 12 brands of ketchup, searching for that idyllic flavor profile.

I was curious to see how all the ketchups would rate tasted side-by-side with no accompaniment. Although the brands sampled were regular tomato ketchup, there was a surprising variation in color, texture and flavor. A few tasted like cocktail sauce or canned tomato sauce. Some were sweet and some spicy. Textures ranged from a smooth paste to much more coarse. Clearly, not all ketchup is alike.

This was a blind tasting, meaning tasters didn’t know which ketchup was which. Each participant in the tasting was asked to rate each brand on appearance, aroma, texture and flavor.

I did not buy membership-only club brands because I wanted ketchup the general public had a reasonable chance of buying. Prices have been updated for 2021 based on listed prices at Chicago-area Jewel-Osco stores, Marianos, Trader Joe's and Whole Foods Market.

(Jason Wambsgans/Chicago Tribune; Shannon Kinsella/food styling)

The Best Ketchup You Can Buy at the Store

The Best Ketchup Brands for 2023

We tried 12 ketchup brands to perfect your picnic or backyard barbecue

The Best Ketchup for Your Backyard Barbecue

The 20 Best Ketchup Brands, Blind Taste Tested And Ranked

Heinz Ketchup, Mustard and Relish Picnic Pack, 4 Pack - All Your Favorite Condiments in One Convenient Pack in the Snacks & Candy department at

Heinz Tomato Ketchup Blended With Jalapeno, 14 oz Squeeze Bottle

Healthy, Kid-Tested Barbecue & Picnic Condiments

Heinz Hot & Spicy Tomato Ketchup Blended with TABASCO® Brand Pepper Sauce, 14 oz Bottle

Here Are the Best (and Worst) Brands of Ketchup, Ranked

15 Best Barbecue Sauce Brands of 2024 - Top Bottled BBQ Sauces

The 20 Best Ketchup Brands, Blind Taste Tested And Ranked

The 20 Best Ketchup Brands, Blind Taste Tested And Ranked